top of page

est. 1995

Welcome to Cait and Abby's Bakery in South Orange, NJ

We have been proudly servicing New Jersey for over 20 years as NJ Magazine's #1 Rated Bakery. For nearly 20 years, we have worked to provide our customers with homemade baked goods and a friendly atmosphere. All of our products are baked on-site, from scratch, and with only the freshest ingredients. 

Fresh variety of breads baked daily

Hand-crafted goods made on premise

Custom

cakes for

any occasion

Satisfying Every Taste Bud
View The Gallery

Serving Breakfast and Lunch Daily

Along with our baked goods, we also provide daily breakfast and lunch specials, sandwiches, salads and much more!

All natural and always refreshing Juice Bar

Try our all natural fruit and/or vegetable smoothies jam-packed with nutrients, antioxidants, and incredible flavor.

Join Us on Instagram
@caitandabbysbakery

Need a custom cake?

We can build any custom cake, big or small, for any occasion. Let our cake designers build one for you or design your own and we'll take care of the rest. Please stop in or call to place an order.

973-763-2229

bottom of page